Assumptions
The supply and demand model does not describe all
markets--there is too much diversity in the ways buyers and
sellers interact for one simple model to explain everything.
When we use the supply and demand model to explain a market,
we are implicitly making a number of assumptions about that
market.
Supply and demand analysis assumes competitive markets.
For a supply curve to exist, there must be a large number of
sellers in the market; and for a demand curve to exist,
there must be many buyers. In both cases there must be
enough so that no one believes that what he does will
influence price. In terms that were first introduced into
economics in the 1950s and that have become quite popular,
everyone must be a price taker and no one can be a
price searcher. If there is only one seller, that
seller can search along the demand curve to find the most
profitable price.1 A price taker cannot influence
the price, but must take or leave it. The ordinary consumer
knows the role of price taker well. When he goes to the
store, he can buy one or twenty gallons of milk with no
effect on price. The assumption that both buyers and sellers
are price takers is a crucial assumption, and often it is
not true with regard to sellers. If it is not true with
regard to sellers, a supply curve will not exist because the
amount a seller will want to sell will depend not on price
but on marginal
revenue.
The model of supply and demand also requires that buyers
and sellers be clearly defined groups. Notice that in the
list of factors that affected buyers and sellers, the only
common factor was price. Few people who buy hamburger know
or care about the price of cattle feed or the details of
cattle breeding. Cattle raisers do not care what the income
of the buyers is or what the prices of related goods are
unless they affect the price of cattle. Thus, when one
factor changes, it affects only one curve, not both. When
buyers and sellers cannot be clearly distinguished, as on
the New York Stock Exchange, where the people who are buyers
one minute may be sellers the next, one cannot talk about
distinct and separate supply and demand curves.
The model of supply and demand also assumes that both
buyers and sellers have good information about the product's
qualities and availability. If information is not good, the
same product may sell for a variety of prices. Often,
however, what seems to be the same product at different
prices can be considered a variety of products. A pound of
hamburger for which one has to wait 15 minutes in a
check-out line can be considered a different product from
identical meat that one can buy without waiting.
Finally, for some uses the supply and demand model needs
well-defined private-property rights. Elsewhere,
we discussed how private-property rights and markets provide
one way of coordinating decisions. When property rights are
not clearly defined, the seller may be able to ignore some
of the costs of production, which will then be imposed on
others. Alternatively, buyers may not get all the benefits
from purchasing a product; others may get some of the
benefits without
payment.
Even if the assumptions underlying supply and demand are
not met exactly, and they rarely are, the model often
provides a fairly good approximation of a situation, good
enough so that predictions based on the model are in the
right direction. This ability of the model to predict even
when some assumptions are not quite satisfied is one reason
economists like the model so much.
Next we discuss the process of
adjustment.
  
1 The price searcher can be a
buyer, in which case the buyer searches along the supply
curve for the best position. In this case a demand curve
will not exist, since the amount the buyer will want to buy
will depend not on price, but on marginal
cost. Price and marginal cost are
identical for a price taker.
Copyright
Robert Schenk
|